Objectives of the service
This service is meant to address the needs of the Maritime Authorities in charge of the enforcement of the ship emission regulations. The ECA areas have specific restrictions concerning the type of fuel that is allowed to be used by shipping vessels, and especially concerning the rate of Sulphur Oxides (SOx) per unit of mass contained inside the fuel. Since January 1st 2015, the MARPOL Annex VI limits the use of fuels containing sulphur oxides to 0.1% of SOx per unit of fuel mass. In this feasibility study, it is intended to assess the feasibility and sustainability of a technique bringing into play Remotely Piloted Aircraft System (RPAS) and satellite technologies.
Users and their needs
The users/customers are the maritime authorities required by the Sulphur Directive to fully implement a mandatory sampling and analysis regime with the samples being representative of marine fuel being used by vessels while travelling:
- Inside ECAs ((this also applies to countries inside ECAs but that may not be inside the EU, like Russia)
- Outside ECAs, but still, inside EU member states EEZs (Exclusive Economic Zone), like Italy or Greece, which still must comply with the EC directive.
The countries that are part of the European Union are represented by the European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA), which has already put in place a system named Thetis dedicated to the collection of information for the enforcement of sulphur controls. In addition, in 2016 the EMSA placed an invitation to tender for RPAS-based services in the maritime environment dedicated to the monitoring of ship emissions.
The main user need identified is to verify the sulphur fuel content of ships navigating in a given area. The proposed solution is to use RPAS to monitor the exhaust gas emission
Service/ system concept
The STEAM service is dedicated to the monitoring of gas emission (SO2, CO2, NOx) in the ship exhaust using an RPAS equipped with appropriate gas sensors. The final product of the service is information on the fuel sulphur content for each ship which is checked.
The customer/user provides a mission specification including the area of control, the period of observations, and the objectives of monitoring observations.
The proposed system architecture is presented in the figure below.
The components of this system are:
- a RPAS which will carry the gas sensors
- a RPAS ground control station
- a gas emission payload (sniffing sensors) onboard the RPAS
- an on-site PC for the RPAS configuration/communication and communication with the CLS Centre of Operations (CCO)
- the CLS Centre of Operations (CCO)
These components will interact with:
- Users/Customers interface, among which EMSA, by getting mission/service instructions and by delivering the mission report
- AIS receiver to collect the positions of the vessel to be monitored
- GNSS satellites for geo-positioning the RPAS
- satellites for real time communication such as Iridium constellation
- national authorities for flight permits
Space Added Value
The service uses two space assets:
- the GNSS satellites for geo-positioning the RPAS
- the Iridium satellites for real time communication. It allows to collect the gas emission records in real time at the ground.
The feasibility study started in November 2015. User requirements have been collected, the service and underlying system has been defined, proof of concept flight tests have been performed in Portugal and in Germany, and a worldwide viability analysis has been conducted.
The technical feasibility of the complete STEAM system has been tested in Hamburg in October 2016 during a 4 days’ campaign
BSH (German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency), the partner involved for the validation process of the SFC (Sulphur Fuel Concentration) calculations played a key rule for the preparation of the campaign especially for the flight permit, for the logistic support and for the external measurements of the ship gas emission with Mesmart stations, one fixed and another mobile. EMSA showed a high interested on the UAV flight operational capability and assisted at the tests in Germany.
The Proof of Concept was a full success regarding the following aspects:
- Controlled UAV flight staying over the ship during several minutes at various altitudes,
- Real time acquisition and visualisation of the sensor readings, the UAV data and the AIS data at ground,
- Response of the sensor especially for the NOx as a trigger when entering into a plume,
- Video to drive the flight in real time,
- Complete system coordination and operations.
The Proof of Concept was a partial success and identified the following technical gaps to mitigate:
- Efficiency of the IR camera onboard the UAV to identify the 3D envelop of the ship exhaust gas plume,
- Staying inside a ship’s plume long enough to allow a Sulfur Fuel Content calculation was not an easy task,
- Sulfur Fuel Content calculation could not be realized using the drone measurements, but ground measurements were also not successful, which shows that the conditions (wind, humidity, fog) were not easy to handle to come up with results.
Following the STEAM feasibility study, it is concluded that CLS will continue prospecting opportunities that are going to be multiplied and growing in the coming years, especially in countries subject to specific areas (Sulphur Emission Control Areas, Domestic Emission Control Areas, others), like Canada, China, and the USA, as well as countries for which future SECAs are to be created (Mediterranean Sea, Mexico, Norway, Japan, Singapore).
In addition, regarding the specific outcomes of the Proof of concept performed in Hamburg, the technical area in which CLS has the most progress to make is the efficient and operational detection of the vessel’s emission plume, and the process to efficiently perform the measurement inside it, especially in windy conditions, as it was the case in Germany.
Finally, CLS takes a step back and is aware that drones as data acquisition platforms, the data they collect, and their applications are part of more global subjects of high importance nowadays, meaning maritime awareness and intelligence, big data, e-navigation, etc. CLS intends therefore to continue working towards staying a major maritime intelligence actor in a global vision where solutions for maritime emissions enforcement opportunities are only a small puzzle piece, but still stay an important opportunity.
The feasibility study was completed in February 2017.